BookSense

Book lists

Books like Things We Never Got Over

Loved Things We Never Got Over by Lucy Score? Here are 10 books with the same pull, and why each one fits.

About Things We Never Got Over →

10 books

Show only
  1. 1It Happened One Summer

    It Happened One Summer

    Tessa Bailey

    Features a fish-out-of-water heroine stranded in a quirky coastal town who clashes with a bearded, grumpy protector with a hidden heart of gold.

    Buy on Amazon
  2. 2In a Jam

    In a Jam

    Kate Canterbary

    Shares the premise of a heroine taking sudden guardianship of a young girl in a small town, paired with a bearded, steadfast local hero.

    Buy on Amazon
  3. 3When in Rome

    When in Rome

    Sarah Adams

    Like Naomi, an overwhelmed heroine flees her life, gets stranded in a quirky small town, and falls for an exasperated, grumpy local shopkeeper.

    Buy on Amazon
  4. 4Part of Your World

    Part of Your World

    Abby Jimenez

    Blends sharp comedic banter and small-town warmth as a polished city heroine finds refuge and love with a rugged, protective local craftsman.

    Buy on Amazon
  5. 5Indigo Ridge

    Indigo Ridge

    Devney Perry

    Combines small-town Montana charm, a grumpy-sunshine dynamic, and a gripping mystery subplot just like the suspenseful turns in Knockemout.

    Buy on Amazon
  6. 6Wait For It

    Wait For It

    Mariana Zapata

    Echoes the sudden guardianship theme and slow-burning romance between an overwhelmed caregiver and her protective, brooding neighbor.

    Buy on Amazon
  7. 7Flawless

    Flawless

    Elsie Silver

    Brings the same vibrant small-town atmosphere, grumpy-meets-sunshine chemistry, and high-heat banter that made Score's story so addictive.

    Buy on Amazon
  8. 8Lovelight Farms

    Lovelight Farms

    B.K. Borison

    Captures the cozy, meddling small-town community vibe and playful romantic banter that fans of Lucy Score adore.

    Buy on Amazon
  9. 9Truth or Beard

    Truth or Beard

    Penny Reid

    Set in a tight-knit Appalachian town full of eccentric locals, bearded protective brothers, and witty, banter-filled romance.

    Buy on Amazon
  10. 10The Coppersmith Farmhouse

    The Coppersmith Farmhouse

    Devney Perry

    Blends a single mom starting over in rural Montana, a gruff protective hero, and an underlying suspense plot that keeps the stakes high.

    Buy on Amazon

Want picks just for you? Tell us books you love.

Wrote a book on this list? Get a badge for your site

More book lists